Can You Eat Too Much Fat on Carnivore? Signs You Might Be Overdoing It
Explore the fine line between high fat and fat overload with real-world tips and healing adjustments
When I first started carnivore, I believed what everyone said: eat more fat. Fat is fuel. Fat heals. Fat makes carnivore sustainable.
And that was true... until it wasn’t.
I found myself getting queasy after meals, bloated, sluggish, even light-headed. My skin broke out. My sleep felt off. I felt heavy and weirdly hungry at the same time. I kept thinking, "Why does everyone say this is supposed to feel amazing?"
Turns out, I was doing what a lot of us do: chasing the "fat equals freedom" mantra so hard that I ignored the signals my body was sending.
If you’re here, wondering whether your fat intake is helping or hurting—you’re not crazy. And you’re definitely not alone.
Why Fat Is Crucial (But Not Infinite)
Fat is essential on carnivore. It protects your hormones, fuels your brain, gives your meals satisfaction and staying power. It helps regulate appetite and keeps blood sugar stable.
But there’s a tipping point.
Too much fat, too fast, or the wrong kinds of fat can overwhelm your digestion, backfire on your energy, and leave you wondering if you’re doing something wrong.
You’re not. You just need to adjust.
Common Signs You Might Be Overdoing Fat
Here’s what to look for:
Loose stools or oily toilet water (sorry, but real talk)
Queasiness after meals, especially with rendered fats like tallow or lard
Burping or reflux after fatty cuts
Feeling heavy, sluggish, or brain-foggy
Persistent breakouts or skin inflammation
Sudden loss of appetite or nausea toward meat
These symptoms aren’t failures. They’re feedback. Your body is trying to say, "Help me process this."
What Causes Fat Overload on Carnivore
Too Much Rendered Fat: Adding scoops of tallow, butter, or lard on top of already fatty meats can overwhelm your bile production. Your gallbladder needs time to catch up.
Eating Too Fast: Gulping down fat-heavy meals doesn't give your body a chance to emulsify and digest properly.
Underproducing Stomach Acid or Bile: If you have a history of low-fat eating, gallbladder issues, or gut dysfunction, you may not be producing enough bile or enzymes yet.
Overdoing Dairy or Egg Yolks: High-fat dairy and eggs can be inflammatory for some people, especially early on.
Gentle Fixes That Work
Here’s how I adjusted without giving up fat altogether:
Stick to whole food fats like ribeye, pork belly, lamb shoulder, and salmon. Let the fat come with the meat.
Ease up on added fats: Instead of pouring tallow on everything, try cooking your meat in the fat and leaving the rest on the pan.
Use digestive bitters or ox bile before meals if you suspect bile issues (check with a professional if unsure).
Chew thoroughly and don’t eat distracted. Mindful eating helps more than people think.
Split meals: If a meal leaves you too full or bloated, try eating half, then finishing the rest 1–2 hours later.
Listen to Your Body, Not Just the Macros
I used to think carnivore was all about the right ratios. But now I know it’s about the right rhythm.
Sometimes that means more fat. Sometimes that means less. Healing isn’t a numbers game—it’s a conversation.
If you’re feeling off, don’t power through blindly. Step back. Adjust. Test. Track. And trust.
Your body wants to heal. You just need to give it the space and support to do it.
Final Thoughts
Fat is medicine. But too much medicine, too soon, can become a stressor.
Don’t be afraid to pull back, simplify, and find your sweet spot. Healing is personal. And sustainable carnivore is about tuning in, not just tuning out the noise.
You don’t have to be perfect. You just have to keep learning.
One honest meal at a time. 🥩
So want to take control of your health and mindset?
Subscribe to my YouTube channel, Billy Poon, for video essays, health content, and practical strategies to level up your life.
Don’t miss out—hit that subscribe button now!
📝 Love real, raw, and helpful writing?
Check out my Medium blog where I dive deep into health, mindset, and personal transformation.
Read and follow here: Billy Poon on Medium
Want to lose 100 lbs, break food addiction, and feel unstoppable in just 1 year?
Get my book Meat Over Mindset — the exact plan I used to drop 75 lbs and reclaim my energy, focus, and life.
Grab your copy now on Amazon here.
