How Often Should I Eat on Carnivore? Listening to Real Hunger

Breaking free from diet dogma and relearning how to fuel your body with honesty, not rules

Photo by Sarah Shull on Unsplash

When I first started carnivore, I felt lost.

Some people said OMAD (one meal a day) was the key to healing.
Others preached 2MAD, or eating until “uncomfortably full” so I could go long stretches without food.
And a few made me feel like if I didn’t fast 20 hours a day, I was doing it wrong.

But here’s what no one really said:

What works is what works for you. And the only way to figure that out is to start listening.

So let’s strip away the noise and get to the heart of the question: How often should you eat on carnivore?

Why “Eat When Hungry” Sounds Simple (But Feels Hard)

On paper, carnivore is supposed to make this easy.
Your blood sugar stabilizes, your cravings drop, and you finally get to feel natural hunger cues again.

But in reality?
Many of us start this diet coming from years of:

• Dieting and restricting

• Binge cycles

• Emotional eating

• Carb addiction

• Fasting because we felt we “should”

And that means we don’t trust our hunger signals anymore.

So when someone says, “Just eat when hungry,” it can feel like they’re speaking a foreign language.

How I Rebuilt Trust With My Body

I had to go back to basics. Here’s what helped me:

1. I started with 2–3 meals a day, no fasting window goal.
   I ate when I felt genuinely hungry. If I wasn’t sure, I ate anyway—but something simple, like plain ground beef, not “fun food.”

2. I noticed how I felt after eating.
   If I felt calm, satisfied, and stable—that was real hunger I’d answered.
   If I felt stuffed, bloated, or anxious—I’d probably eaten out of habit or emotion.

3. I stopped glorifying huge meals.
   I realized that trying to eat giant portions to “get through the day on one meal” left me feeling heavy and off.

4. I stopped looking at the clock.
   Eating became about my body—not the hour.

So… How Often Should You Eat?

There’s no universal rule, but here’s what I recommend, especially in your first 3–6 months:

• Start with 2–3 meals spaced 4–6 hours apart.
  This helps stabilize energy and digestion while you recalibrate your hunger signals.

• Prioritize nutrient density in each meal.
  Fatty cuts, salt, and enough volume to feel satisfied—not stuffed.

• Let your hunger adjust over time.
  As your body heals, you may naturally move to 1–2 meals without forcing it.

• Don’t fast aggressively until your body asks for it.
  If you’re not hungry at breakfast anymore? Great. But don’t skip because a podcast told you to.

Signs You’re Eating at the Right Frequency

✅ Your energy feels steady—not crashing mid-afternoon
✅ You sleep deeply and wake up refreshed
✅ You feel calm and focused—not jittery or obsessing about your next meal
✅ Your digestion is smooth
✅ You don’t feel deprived

Signs You Might Need to Adjust

⚠️ You’re forcing down huge portions but feel heavy or nauseous
⚠️ You’re constantly thinking about food
⚠️ You’re tired, foggy, or irritable
⚠️ You feel weak or dizzy between meals
⚠️ You’re using coffee or stimulants to bridge long gaps

Final Thoughts

Carnivore gives you a chance to finally break free from diet dogma—but only if you stop trying to follow someone else’s hunger and start tuning in to your own.

There is no gold star for OMAD. No medal for fasting longer.

The real win is feeling safe in your body again—feeding it when it asks, trusting it to tell you the truth, and building meals that heal instead of harm.

So how often should you eat?
As often as your body asks—and as much as your healing requires.

One honest meal at a time. 🥩

So want to take control of your health and mindset?

Subscribe to my YouTube channel, Billy Poon, for video essays, health content, and practical strategies to level up your life.

Don’t miss out—hit that subscribe button now!

📝 Love real, raw, and helpful writing?

Check out my Medium blog where I dive deep into health, mindset, and personal transformation.

Read and follow here: Billy Poon on Medium

Want to lose 100 lbs, break food addiction, and feel unstoppable in just 1 year?

Get my book Meat Over Mindset — the exact plan I used to drop 75 lbs and reclaim my energy, focus, and life.

Grab your copy now on Amazon here.